Energy-related policymaking often separates climate, health, and affordability into different segments. Therefore, policy focused on reducing climate-warming emissions may not address, or in some cases worsen energy affordability issues, for instance. Our fine-scaled data lets policymakers find solutions that address all three factors at the same time: reducing household costs, improving home health, and cutting greenhouse gas emissions.
Energy equity means affordable, safe, and reliable energy for all, regardless of income, ownership status, race, where they live, or home type. Equity-focused clean energy policies ensure that households that cannot afford the upfront costs of clean energy and already face disproportionate burdens from fossil energy are not left behind in the energy transition.
Decades of policies like redlining have left many groups (including communities of color and rural neighborhoods) chronically underserved, in less efficient housing stock and with unreliable power service and high utility bills. These same communities also tend to be most burdened by pollution from fossil fuel infrastructure like power plants and pipelines.
We evaluate energy equity through metrics of affordability, reliability, resilience, and health. Energy affordability assesses how high households’ energy bills are and whether they are affordable based on household income. It is measured through metrics like energy cost burden and the energy affordability gap. Reliability refers to how consistent and dependable power service is for a given community – an area experiencing regular power outages has low power reliability. Resilience measures a household or community’s ability to withstand and maintain essential services through increasingly severe climate and weather impacts, such as heat waves, wildfires, smoke, floods, and storms. These metrics, along with direct emissions of nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, and other compounds from gas appliances, affect the health and quality of life of a household’s residents. Communities may rank highly on one metric and poorly on others.
Energy cost burden (ECB) is the percentage of gross household income spent on home energy. A household earning $40,000 and spending $2,400 on electricity and heating fuel has an ECB of 6%.
Researchers commonly define an ECB of 6% or more as high. This standard comes from 1960s federal housing assistance programs that set the cutoff at households spending more than 25% of income on rent. This number was increased to 30% in the 1980s. The 6% ECB level assumes that households spend no more than one-fifth of housing costs on energy (one-fifth of 30% = 6%). Some policymakers use the 6% ECB level to identify energy-insecure households that would qualify for assistance programs. ECB does not account for other household costs, such as medical care, food, childcare, and debt; therefore, although it serves as a baseline metric, households can still feel the pinch of energy bills even if they spend less than 6% of their income on energy.
High energy cost burdens are not evenly shared. Two-thirds of low-income households are cost-burdened. Communities of color and rural communities also face high energy cost burdens. Expensive fuels like propane and fuel oil can drive up heating bills. Older homes also tend to be less efficient, with poor insulation and inefficient appliances, which raises bills for residents. Home weatherization, energy efficiency, solar, and batteries can ease these burdens, but their prohibitive upfront costs limit access for low-income households and renters who do not own their homes.
The consequences of high energy bills are acutely tangible. Across the country, one in three households struggles to pay energy bills, one in five reports skipping essentials like food or healthcare to cover them, and one in seven has received a disconnection notice.
Another metric to measure energy insecurity is the Affordability Gap. Put simply, it is the dollar amount a household pays beyond 6% of their income. For instance, a household that makes $30,000 annually and pays $3,000 a year in energy bills would have a 10% ECB. This exceeds the ECB threshold by 4% – meaning that they are paying $1200 more per year than they should (0.04*30,000 = 1,200). This household is unlikely to be able to afford their energy costs and likely qualifies for public assistance. Put another way, the Affordability Gap represents the dollar amount required to bring households down out of energy insecurity. The Affordability Gap can be summed for households across a given area or demographic to show the cumulative excess energy expenses incurred by this population. The total Affordability Gap across a county or state can be millions to tens of millions of dollars.
The Affordability Gap is based on the 6% ECB threshold. As stated above, households with ECBs below 6% can still feel financially strained. Some argue for lowering the 6% threshold to 3% or to a state median value, which would increase the Affordability Gap.
Historically, most energy burden analyses use a representative sample of households that reflects a state’s population, ensuring different demographics, home types, and rural or urban residents are adequately represented. Researchers then calculate the average ECB across these samples and within demographic groups. However, this approach may obscure those who struggle most, because samples may not reflect the full population, and averages across a census tract, for example, can hide the true range of energy poverty. One area may have dozens of mobile homes, whose residents face acute energy burdens, but also a few wealthy landowners who are not energy-burdened. When averaged together, the area may appear to have a low ECB, so policymakers may miss the mobile home residents. Our household-level data avoids this issue by allowing users to filter specifically for mobile home residents and visualize the total excess energy costs they pay, rather than seeing an average value for the neighborhood.
PSE used this methodology and our household dataset to advise policy in states like Maryland and Colorado. In Maryland, we estimated the total energy affordability gap at roughly $400 million a year, exceeding the cost of energy-efficiency, weatherization, or clean-energy policies that would reduce it.
In Colorado, our analysis for the Colorado Energy Office showed that climate goals that do not account for equity and affordability may worsen burdens on communities that already struggle. Expanding equity-focused energy policies in burdened communities lowers bills for those who need it most while still helping the state meet its climate goals.
Public data tools, such as the U.S. Department of Energy’s LEAD tool, provide a useful starting point for communities. Most, though, report averages for large areas and broad demographic groups. That makes it hard to see which specific types of households are struggling. Most existing tools also tend to show the problem, not the impacts of potential solutions. A policymaker deciding where to invest limited dollars needs a sharper picture than a regional average provides.
Increasing geographic resolution changes decisions. When North Carolina-based nonprofit Appalachian Voices asked PSE to help understand customers of nonprofit electric cooperatives, our scientists pulled together all available data and distilled affordability trends to the neighborhood scale for each cooperative’s customers, rather than the census tract or county scale. That view lets advocates and utilities focus on the people hit hardest. For instance, low-income rural cooperative customers struggle with large, old homes and a reliance on expensive delivered fuels. These customers would stand to benefit disproportionately from electrification and weatherization.
Prior affordability analysis has also tended to ignore resilience. A household that can pay its monthly bill may still be one outage away from a crisis, especially if someone relies on refrigerated medication or powered medical equipment. As worsening climate phenomena like heat waves become more common, households may rely even more on electrical appliances like air conditioning to stay safe, which can further raise their bills. Our Equity in Energy Resilience report developed metrics to incorporate equity into power outage impact analyses, including measures of a household’s resilient energy burden and resilient energy affordability gap that highlight the cost burden and affordability gap for households when outage costs are taken into account.
Energy insecurity is a public health issue. Households that can’t afford to adequately heat or cool their homes face greater exposure to unsafe temperatures. Those who skip necessities like food or medical needs to keep the lights and heat on face added health burdens. Additionally, burning fossil fuels at home in furnaces, water heaters, and stoves releases pollutants such as nitrogen oxide, which pose additional direct health risks, especially for vulnerable people like children, the elderly, and those with pre-existing health concerns.
Energy efficiency, weatherization, and clean energy upgrades can cut bills and emissions at the same time. Appliance efficiency improvements, home weatherization, and demand response programs reduce how much energy a household needs to purchase. Clean energy upgrades, like solar and storage, can provide electricity that households no longer have to purchase from a utility, and in some cases, households can sell excess electricity back to the utility, netting additional profit. However, access is not currently equitable. Upfront costs, split incentives between landlords and tenants, and limited information keep many of the highest-burden households from benefiting.
If the transition is designed without accounting for equity, it can widen existing gaps. Households that can afford solar panels, batteries, or energy-efficient appliances can break away from utility power, but those that cannot afford these solutions remain stuck on aging and increasingly expensive infrastructure. These tend to be disproportionately low-income, rural, and/or communities of color. Designing policies so clean energy and efficiency measures target the most vulnerable communities ensures cost reductions deliver maximum impact while cutting health-damaging, climate-warming pollution.
After developing detailed affordability models for our work in states like Colorado, Maryland, and Virginia, we set out to launch a tool that provides household-level data on energy use, costs, and demographics nationwide. This tool would be free and publicly accessible, giving policymakers, community advocates, and researchers the ability to generate locally relevant policy solutions that may have previously been locked behind technical, paywalled data. CEIM will be launching in early 2027.
Many existing resources provide average energy cost burdens at the state, county, or census-tract level. CEIM shows what sits beneath that average: how burdens vary across households and neighborhoods, across comprehensive demographic groups. CEIM frames the issue not just by a group’s mean energy cost burden, but by the total excess costs paid, showing the true scale of the energy affordability crisis. Additionally, the tool lets users simulate how various energy policies (e.g., changes in utility rates, new efficiency measures, or clean energy adoption) would affect total excess costs paid across different groups. This lets users see the cumulative excess energy costs paid by a specific demographic (for instance, low-income renters in Los Angeles, CA) and how targeted policy solutions (community or plug-in solar, electrification) can lower their bills.
Our work in Colorado and Maryland showed that household-level modeling could produce more accurate estimates of affordability gaps than tract or county-level averages. They also showed how to connect those estimates to decarbonization planning so equity and affordability shape climate strategy from the start. CEIM extends that approach to the national level.
We have built CEIM for state and local policymakers, regulators, utilities, community organizations, and researchers. Users should be able to see how energy burden and affordability gaps vary by place and across different demographics, and to explore how targeted investments in specific communities may change them.
State and federal governments have invested billions in bill assistance and energy-saving programs, and many have set ambitious climate targets for the next several years. However, more accurate data would allow policymakers to allocate these resources more efficiently. If policymakers can identify the neighborhoods and household types with the largest affordability gaps, as well as the drivers of these gaps, they can prioritize programs that address the root cause of these excess costs, thereby reducing costs while also reducing the amount of bill assistance paid out by governments, utilities, or ratepayers.
Utility planning generally focuses on least-cost upgrades, maintenance, and power sourcing while still maintaining reliable service. However, including household-level equity and affordability data changes what “least-cost” looks like. This data can inform planners on how policies, like rate increases, would affect customers least able to absorb them, while also providing more accurate estimates of the benefits of interventions like efficiency programs, demand response, or community solar.
Community groups often know what’s happening on the ground but lack the numbers to make their case in a regulatory proceeding or funding application. CEIM lets communities turn lived experience into concrete data they can present to decision-makers to pass actionable policy.
For communities that want to go a step further, our Community Science Consulting team offers direct technical assistance to community groups and advocates who may lack technical expertise on their own teams. Launched in 2023, this team works with community partners to understand their experience, identify the research questions with the greatest potential for impact, carry out the analysis, and share findings as issue briefs, presentations, and data visualizations.
This 2024 technical report examined how equity and energy resilience intersect, and introduced the resilient energy burden and resilient energy affordability gap measures described above. It laid the groundwork for treating resilience as part of affordability instead of a separate topic.
In February 2023, Appalachian Voices contacted PSE for help understanding which customers in electric cooperatives are financially strained by energy bills and what actions utilities can take to reduce those energy bills. This project showed how neighborhood-scale affordability analysis can support a community organization’s advocacy. It also showed a real appetite for this kind of data among groups that had few options for getting it.
Home electrification and efficiency solutions can also reduce reliance on polluting fossil fuel power plants, many of which (peaker plants) are particularly expensive and inefficient to run. Our California Power Map and peaker plant replacement tools assess the dirtiest, most expensive, and inefficient power plants across several states, which would be ideal candidates to be replaced with cheaper battery storage solutions. Households with energy-efficient appliances, solar, batteries, or other clean energy solutions can also reduce their overall reliance on expensive power plants feeding the grid, which should reduce costs.
Climate change is straining our energy systems. More frequent heat waves increase power demand, extreme events can damage power infrastructure, and utilities often cut power during wildfire conditions. These pressures hit the most vulnerable households hardest. Equity should be the starting point in energy planning, not an afterthought.
We’ll share updates on CEIM as the launch approaches. You can follow our work and join our mailing list through the PSE Healthy Energy website to hear when the tool goes live in February 2027.
Energy equity refers to inequities embedded in our current energy systems, including the siting and pollution from power plants, pipelines, and other infrastructure; access to affordable, reliable power; access to safe, healthy energy options; and the ability to weather rising costs. Energy affordability is a subsect of energy equity, and specifically examines whether households can afford the energy that powers their homes, which is an essential part of modern life. Energy affordability examines who can and cannot afford their basic energy needs, the root social, economic, and environmental factors driving high energy costs, and solutions aimed at lowering costs for those who are the most burdened.
Researchers generally consider spending 6% of gross household income on energy needs as the threshold, beyond which households are considered energy insecure or energy cost burdened. The burden increases in severity as the percentage rises, with households above 10% cost burden considered “energy impoverished.” However, as mentioned earlier, this metric does not account for other myriad expenses; a household paying high costs for debt, childcare, medical care, and food may consider energy costs burdensome even if they are under the 6% threshold.
Low-income households do not necessarily have larger bills or use more energy. In fact, research shows these households tend to use less energy and spend less on energy overall. However, as energy prices are fairly inelastic, low-income households end up spending a larger proportion of their income than their higher-income counterparts. For example, let’s say two households, A and B, both spend $2,000 annually on their energy bills. However, household A earns $80,000, while household B earns $20,000. Household A has an ECB of 2.5%, while household B has an ECB of 10%. Low-income households like household B are also more likely to live in older, less efficient housing and may have limited ability to make home or energy upgrades to reduce their annual bills.
Energy reliability refers to the grid’s ability to provide consistent power and avoid outages. Energy resilience is a household’s or community’s ability to withstand outages and/or extreme climate events, such as heat waves, storms, or wildfires.
CEIM will be open-access and free-to-use. We will publish our methodology on our website and offer technical assistance and support for organizations that want to learn to use the tool and for those who want to use our data to perform analyses beyond what CEIM can do.
CEIM will launch in early 2027. Follow PSE’s website or sign up for our mailing list for the latest updates.